Delta Air Lines

GREAT RESTAURANTS ~ SUPERB FOOD ~ THE BEST WINES

ABOUT US       DINING IN PARIS       REGIONS OF FRANCE       ARTICLES       WINE      CHEESE      RECIPES

Paris Dining GuidesBest Paris RestaurantsSuperior French Dining WorldwideBook Shop

 
Rosetta Stone: Choose from 30 Languages

Les Ambassadeurs – Paris (Rating: 17/20)

The Gastroville Review: January 10, 2007

LES AMBASSADEURS – ALMOST PERFECT INGREDIENTS BUT IMPERFECT CONCEPTION

Readers may remember the two fantastic meals I had earlier this year at Les Ambassadeurs. Several dishes, the fantastic Cevennes onion tart, the sweet breads and the huge scallop with a perfect vinaigrette all rest in clear memory. In fact the onion tart bears the signs of one of those rare really great dishes that seem to grow in grandness in memory as time passes. Also not to forget was the Galician beef, a real pièce de résistance (also in its original meaning). So it was with perhaps unrealistic expectations I revisited les Ambassadeurs a couple of weeks ago. Since it was the end of the white truffle season and the beginning of the black truffle season, it seemed like a good time to go.

The reason the March meals impressed me so much was not only the incredible quality of the ingredients, but also the sophistication, clarity and perhaps most importantly the yet obvious greatness and class of some dishes. Although Piège's compositions have a tendency to be a bit complicated, some of them still bore simplicity in terms of flavours and clarity.

This more recent December meal confirmed yet again that the ingredients sourcing at Les Ambassadeurs is simply mind boggling. Literally everything is perfect. There are few restaurants in the world were such meticulously selected ingredients are served consistently throughout a meal and throughout meals. This was my fourth meal under Piège’s tenure at Les Ambassadeurs and I continue to be surprised at very high level of ingredients served. Quite a feat. Well, almost perfect, as it says in the header. The white truffles served were somewhat muted as were the black ones. Even if it is early in the season for the black, I have had significantly better black truffles scored on the “black market” this season.

Piège's strengths in my opinion lie in when he modernises classic French dishes or dishes with roots in French classic cooking and without compromising the deliciousness by overly complicated presentations and applying modern techniques achieves a result that feels so obviously great. His onion tart in March was an example of this as were the fantastic endives with ham and truffles from a meal just after Piège took charge of Les Ambassadeurs. I think however that some dishes become overly complicated. Like his casse-croûte of lobster in March and when he used the same concept for the scallops and pumpkin in this more recent meal.

Piège composed a meal for us that featured some white truffle and black truffle dishes as well as his signature dish langoustines with caviar.

The meal started with Piège’s TV-platter. It was somewhat changed since March, although only in the details. Although all items are well conceived and well made, for the frequent goer may like some alternation. The one objection I may have is the cylinder with snails’ mousse inside. On the three occasions I have had it; I have not managed to eat it without dripping on the napkin. A cornet would be more convenient although perhaps less original for Piège.

The first dish served was one of Piège's signature dishes Caviar golden d'Iran/nage corsée/langoustines. As can be expected here, the langoustines were of unbelievable quality or perhaps like Nerieds disguised as langoustines, which a good friend once said when commenting on the quality of langoustines he had at L'Ambroisie. The caviar was good; even Vedat, who knows his caviar from consuming huge quantities of black market caviar over the years in Istanbul, would have conceded that the caviar was of good quality. So what is there not to like? Well, the langoustines explained to be “en tempura” were deep fried in a wrapper of a dough that was somewhat crispy on the exterior but almost soggy inside and a little too greasy, which all somewhat tainted the impression of eating the langoustines. The wrapper has really nothing to do with tempura and is hardly an improvement over a feather light perfect tempura like Gagnaire can serve instance. It is really not an improvement as a trial to remake tempura. Actually, serving the langoustines in this poor spring roll style fashion has improved nothing compared to just serving them as they are in the natural state cooked in any fashion. The side dish of nage corsée was well made but the sushi style piece of langoustine with it made little sense. Langoustines are in my opinion not one of the most interesting produce from the sea to eat sushi style unless cut very thinly. Although this dish displayed fantastic ingredients and impressive craftsmanship, I frankly find it overreaching and boring.

The egg dish that came next was much better. Like an oeuf Florentine but served as a golf ball sized cracking cromesqui of egg yolk. It was really excellent, and to my taste better than Pacaud’s more classic Florentine egg version, although the shell appeared slightly too thick and the squeeze effect of punching a hole in it stained on my jacket. This dish displayed that fantastic deliciousness that Piège can capture in remaking a classic dish.

The rolled toasted bread came next, or casse-croûte of lobster as it was called in March. This time it was filled with scallops and pumpkin slices. It was served with Alba truffles slices and slices of pumpkin chips. Scallops and pumpkin go very well together. The two different sweet notes of the two produce marry in an interesting manner. The white truffles were rather muted although to the restaurant’s defence it was cut in pretty generous and thick slices. The scallops came across as imperfectly prepared. Personally, I find this preparation a good example of when a dish is over worked and when the visual presentation of the dish seems to have gotten priority over the appearance in taste and mouth feel. The dish becomes more of a decoration rather than being visually appetising.

The probably best dish was the sweetbreads façon Crécy, another squared preparation much favoured by Piège. This was an exceptional dish even if it was eclipsed by the extraordinary sweetbreads dish in March.

Cheeses from Antony were of course a real treat and included fantastic camembert, Saint Nectaire and l’Abbaye de citeaux and a comté from 2003.

Dessert was a variation of one of the desserts from March. Leaving aside that I don’t really favour desserts made with banana for their usually cloying mouth feel, this was excellently made. But again, a bit too much of a decoration.

It was perhaps too much to expect another stunning meal on the level of the ones in March. I am unsure if any restaurant is able to consistently perform on such level. There is no doubt that Piège is a technician in the cuisine that sets a new standard. Having said this it was an excellent meal but my impressions are somewhat negatively affected by the for me somewhat overworked aspects of some preparations. They lack spontaneity, simplicity and obviousness of truly great dishes and I know that Piège is capable of doing better than this. Therefore I rate this meal less than previous meals but it is still a highly recommended restaurant that is one of very few that is capable of turning out extraordinary preparations. It will be interesting to follow Piège's developments.

Gastroville rating of this meal: 17/20.

It will be interesting to see if Michelin will elevate Les Ambassadeurs to 3 stars next year. Even if this last meal was not as great as the two March meals, it did prove that it is a restaurant with consistent high performances and Les Ambassadeurs is clearly performing better than many French 3-star restaurants and probably most non-French. Piège is also, with Cordeillan Bages, the one that has impressed most on me and Vedat of the current espoirs whereas for example Le Meurice provided me a really disappointing meal in March that was simply not acceptable for the prices these meals command.

Finally a few word about the excellent wine service at Les Ambassadeurs as it deserves special mentioning. Not only is the wine list very extensive and well chosen, but there are also – not common for Paris – a number of relative bargains. It also highly recommended to seek advice from the knowledgeable David Biraud who is the Chef sommelier and responsible for the wine service.

David recommended a 1993 Meursault-Perriers from Roulot and it turned out to be quite a surprise. I had the last of my own bottles from this vintage before 2000 and asked the several times if the wine was not past its prime. David persisted that it was not. The first tastes revealed a fully mature Meursault, but the real surprise came later during the meal when the wine, after having been opened for a while, changed completely and smelled and tasted like a much younger wine. It was quite a stunning wine for lovers of the style in which Jean Marc Roulot makes his wines. We followed with a 1991 Pommard Rugiens from Hubert de Montille which must be considered as one of the excellent value at this restaurant.

Mikael

Les Ambassadeurs – Paris (Rating: 19/20)

The Gastroville Review: March 22, 2006

Vedat and I have taken a particularly interest in visiting the up and coming French restaurants or the so called espoirs to gain the coveted Michelin 3-star rating. On a recent Paris trip I had Le Meurice and Les Ambassadeurs on the program. It was not without some skepticism I returned to Les Ambassadeurs to again try Jean-François Piège's cuisine. Vedat and I ate there shortly after he had installed himself after leaving Alain Ducasse at Plaza Athénée. We had a very good meal prepared with superb ingredients that we rated highly. What caused my skepticism were several articles about Piège and his food and a few TV coverage of him left me a little worried that the signs we noted of overcomplicating things and turning the food into architectural creations had gone a little astray.

I was more than a little worried that the Cartesian style and perhaps we could say somewhat baroque creations had become far too baroque. It turned out that my fears were completely wrong.

It is easy to be impressed by Jean François Piège's cuisine. I am not sure there is a current Chef in haute cuisine anywhere that cooks with such precision like the kitchen of Les Ambassadeurs under Piège. I don’t think so. The technique is virtually flawless and from my point of view clearly today’s benchmark. The used techniques manage to cleverly balance modern techniques and traditional techniques. The ingredients are throughout a meal as good as it gets or close to and especially impressive is the now in most dishes superb calibration of tastes and taste marriages, which Vedat and I somewhat missed on our fist meal. I sense more creativity on the two meals I had now than on the first occasions as if Piège is more liberated from the influence of having been under the Ducasse umbrella for many years and he is now finding his own style. The said praise does not mean that I do not have some issues with Piège’s cuisine. I do find some sauces a notch too reduced or with slightly too much fat traces but this all fall under the category of a matter of taste.

Many dishes bear a hallmark of Piège’s playfulness and creativity without forgetting the roots of French cuisine and without compromising the in so many places missing rigor necessary to obtain a truly extraordinary result.

I had two meals there recently. Both meals started with the amuse “Sur l’idée d’un plateau de télé…..”. It is perhaps as far as one can get from most people’s normal television snacks, but it is a very good start of a meal. It consisted of Gateau de foie blond selon Lucien Tendret version 2006 (A small glass of cray fish and chicken liver mousse), Variation croustillante d’une tranche de jambon (a deep fried crocquet), Comme un jambon/buerre à la parisienne (a cigarette-like crisp filled with airlight mousse), Bonbon, buerre de truffe noire a tartiner (truffles butter to spread on a toast) and last and perhaps most impressive of all, salade de betterave en lemonade (a beet soda with a clear and crisp taste of beets).

The dish of the two meals I had at Les Ambassadeurs was the sweetbreads done two ways with a salad of endives and ham. One large chunk of pink cooked with a superb outside crust was paired with smaller soft cooked pieces and a superb endive and ham salad prepared with endive leaves that had been trimmed from their most bitter parts. It is rare to find sweetbreads on this level. Indeed I find it not really worth eating sweetbreads if they are not of top notch quality. Also somewhat disturbing is the fashion to cook them in smaller pieces in order to caramelise them with the result of rather dry interior albeit some crispiness or rather a not so desirable crunchiness is obtained. I take my hat of for Piège´s preparation. Bravo.

Another dish on the first meal that was simply a superb dish flirting with perfection in my book was a very large scallop from Erquy served with a leeks compression with truffles, a fantastic vinaigrette and a truffle foam. The scallop was superbly cooked showing both texture and taste of the pan frying and the textural sensation of a medium rare scallop meat. The vinaigrette was superbly balanced and perfumed.

The dish that I was least impressed with, although it still was a very nice dish, was the “Casse-Croûte” de homard bleu a la Florentine. The truffled sauce was slightly too powerful with too much fat traces for the delicate lobster. But even so it is an admirable dish from a conceptual point of view.

Most dishes had truffles incorporated into them. Unfortunately the truffles somewhat lacked in perfume, but they have most of this year and this year goes to the history as a pretty bad truffle year. There were astonishing truffles in mid-December up until early January and then they faded quickly. Only once in early January did I sense that smoky almost like toasted coffee and extremely pungent flavours that is to die for.

The cheese service at Les Ambassadeurs is heavily focused on cheeses from Bernard Antony who is one of France’s premier cheese affineurs. Some of the musts from him include his vieux comté, currently the 2002, his superb fourme d’Ambert and l’Abbaye de Citeaux.

The desserts at Les Ambassadeurs are perhaps the most complicated and complex preparations from an architectural point of view. From a taste point of view they were still very good even if they are somewhat overworked for my taste. Desserts included a Choco/pamplemousse en chaud/froid, which can be seen on the first picture below and on the second picture below is the Comme un vacherin, noix de cocos/ananas.

Jean-François Piège suggested I should come back and try his Galician beef. It was hard to resist trying a Galician beef killed at 7-9 years of age and then matured for one month. The second meal shortly after the first proved to be another superb meal. First the splendid television platter one more time, then a very good big piece of low heat cooked sea bass that was slightly overwhelmed by a buttery truffle sauce. With the bass were also superb buckwheat pancakes and crepes. The sea bass was followed by another fantastic dish. A tarte of Cevennes onion and a clear soup of Cevennes onions and small onion croquets. I adore Cevennes onions if they are prepared carefully so that their fantastic mild onion taste comes through clearly. Piège’s preparation was a creative version of onion tarte and onion soup. Had I not known it was Piège I may have guessed I was being served it by Gagnaire on one of his better days. I think that this dish is the dish I will remember most from these two meals in the future.

So after quite a lot of food, only a few hours after the first meal it was time for the Galician beef. I was a little anxious since they had shown me the piece in advance and it was a large cut, easily enough to serve two people. It was the second cote from the basse cotes, which is one of my preferred parts of the back of the beef. What made me most curious in advance was that Jean-François told me it was not very far in style from a very good Simmental, only slaughtered when it is older and thereby had more flavour than a Simmental. It was quite marbled even if I have had Simmental with more marbling but it was a very very good beef. The taste was quite gamey but not too gamey to loose its taste of beef.

On our first visit, Vedat and I experienced some service glitches. This is all history and very professional and friendly service is now provided by a well trained and enthusiastic team. Wine service is particularly good. The wine list is huge with some very interesting wines at reasonable prices. A 91 Pommard Rugiens from Hubert de Montille proved to be a lovely wine.

The dining room at Les Ambassadeurs is in my opinion one of the more informal and relaxed of the palace dining rooms of Paris and indeed Europe. One does not feel the opulence of places like le Meurice or Le Louis XV e t c.

I highly recommend Les Ambassadeurs and based on the two meals I had there, Les Ambassadeurs would get my vote as one of the top five restaurants in Paris.

Gastroville rating: 19/20

/ MJ

© 2006, 2007 Gastroville.com.  Used by permission.  All rights reserved. "Gastroville – A Refuge for Foodies" www.Gastroville.com

 

DininginFrance.com encourages you to read our privacy policy.

Copyright © 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008 Internaire.  All rights reserved.